Article
Complete Maytag Wringer Washer Troubleshooting Guide
Learn how to diagnose and repair the most common Maytag wringer washer problems using original factory troubleshooting procedures combined with proven restoration experience. Covers wringer rolls, agitators, oil leaks, water leaks, power unit repairs, and safety mechanisms.
This comprehensive troubleshooting guide helps diagnose virtually every common Maytag wringer washer problem. Using original factory service information and decades of restoration experience, this guide explains the causes, affected components, and recommended repairs for vintage Maytag wringer washers.
Whether your Maytag wringer washer won't agitate, the wringer rolls won't turn, oil is leaking from the transmission, or water is dripping beneath the tub, proper diagnosis is the first step toward a successful repair.
Many owners assume their washer requires a complete rebuild when, in reality, most problems are caused by a handful of wear items such as:
- Bearings
- O-rings
- Seals
- Springs
- Gears
- Stop rings
- Clutch components
- Gaskets
- Actuators
This troubleshooting guide combines original Maytag factory service procedures with additional repair recommendations gathered from years of restoring, rebuilding, and supplying parts for vintage Maytag wringer washers.
Rather than replacing expensive assemblies unnecessarily, use the symptom charts below to locate the actual source of the problem.
Table of Contents
- Washer Will Not Agitate
- Wringer Rolls Will Not Operate
- Wringer Will Not Wring Clothes Dry
- Agitator Rises Off Shaft
- Water Leaks
- Oil Leaks
- Washer Continues to Agitate
- Wringer Assembly Does Not Turn
- Wringer Does Not Lock in Position
- Safety Foot Pedal Problems
- Agitator Floats Up
- Agitator Will Not Remove
- Center Plate Problems
- Transmission Problems
- Recommended Repair Parts
Downloads
- Download
Maytag Lubrication Guide A
- Download
Maytag Lubrication Guide B
- Download
Maytag Wringer Washer Most Common Problems A
- Download
Maytag Wringer Washer Most Common Problems B
- Download
Maytag Wringer Washer Trouble Shooter Guide 1
- Download
Maytag Wringer Washer Trouble Shooter Guide 2
- Download
Maytag Wringer Washer Trouble Shooter Guide 3
- Open link
Maytag Collectors Club Printable Decals
- Open link
Maytag Collectors Club History of The Maytag Company
- Open link
Maytag Service Manual Section 2
- Open link
Maytag Service Manual Section 3
Frequently Asked Questions
Why won't my washer agitate?
Inspect the center plate, agitator shaft, clutch pinion, shifter cam, worm gear, rack gear, and thrust bearing.
Possible Cause
A worn clutch pinion or damaged agitator shaft prevents power from being transferred from the transmission to the agitator.
Components to Inspect
• Center Plate
• Agitator Shaft
• Clutch Pinion
Recommended Repair
Remove the center plate assembly and inspect the clutch pinion, agitator shaft, and gear teeth. Replace any worn, chipped, or damaged components.
If the problem is inside the power unit, also inspect the:
• Center Plate Bearings
• Agitator Shaft
• Shifter Cam
• Worm Gear
• Worm Wheel
• Rack Gear
• Clutch Pinion
• Thrust Bearing
Common symptoms include:
• Motor runs normally
• Agitator does not move
• Grinding noises
• Intermittent operation
If multiple gears are worn, rebuilding the transmission is recommended.
Possible Cause
A worn clutch pinion or damaged agitator shaft prevents power from being transferred from the transmission to the agitator.
Components to Inspect
• Center Plate
• Agitator Shaft
• Clutch Pinion
Recommended Repair
Remove the center plate assembly and inspect the clutch pinion, agitator shaft, and gear teeth. Replace any worn, chipped, or damaged components.
If the problem is inside the power unit, also inspect the:
• Center Plate Bearings
• Agitator Shaft
• Shifter Cam
• Worm Gear
• Worm Wheel
• Rack Gear
• Clutch Pinion
• Thrust Bearing
Common symptoms include:
• Motor runs normally
• Agitator does not move
• Grinding noises
• Intermittent operation
If multiple gears are worn, rebuilding the transmission is recommended.
Why won't my Maytag wringer rolls turn?
Common causes include a failed wringer safety clutch, broken trigger ring, damaged bevel gear, worn clutch springs, broken drive pinion gears, or worn wringer head gears.
Step 1 — Inspect the Safety Clutch
Check the:
• Safety Actuator
• Air Foot Pedal
• Rubber Air Bulb
If the actuator will not hold air pressure, it must be repaired or replaced.
Step 2 — Inspect the Trigger Ring
Look for:
• Broken Trigger Ring
• Broken Trigger Gear
• Broken Clutch Spring
• Worn Bevel Gear
Replace any damaged components.
Step 3 — Inspect the Wringer Head
Inspect the:
• Torque Coupling
• Drive Pinion Gears
• Clutch Springs
• Shifter Springs
• Drive Key
• Crown Gear
Worn gears are one of the most common reasons the wringer rolls fail to turn.
Step 1 — Inspect the Safety Clutch
Check the:
• Safety Actuator
• Air Foot Pedal
• Rubber Air Bulb
If the actuator will not hold air pressure, it must be repaired or replaced.
Step 2 — Inspect the Trigger Ring
Look for:
• Broken Trigger Ring
• Broken Trigger Gear
• Broken Clutch Spring
• Worn Bevel Gear
Replace any damaged components.
Step 3 — Inspect the Wringer Head
Inspect the:
• Torque Coupling
• Drive Pinion Gears
• Clutch Springs
• Shifter Springs
• Drive Key
• Crown Gear
Worn gears are one of the most common reasons the wringer rolls fail to turn.
Why doesn't my wringer squeeze clothes dry?
This is usually caused by a worn lower wringer roll or excessive play in the upper roll bearing hangers.
Inspect
• Lower Wringer Roll
• Upper Roll Bearing Hangers
Replace the lower roll if worn. If the upper bearing hangers have excessive play, install oversized bearing hangers.
Inspect
• Lower Wringer Roll
• Upper Roll Bearing Hangers
Replace the lower roll if worn. If the upper bearing hangers have excessive play, install oversized bearing hangers.
Why is oil leaking from my wringer head?
Oil leaks usually originate from worn O-rings, wringer stem bearings, lower roll shaft seals, or transmission seals.
Inspect
• Cam Shaft O-Ring
• Wringer Stem Bearing
• Lower Roll Shaft O-Ring
Typical signs include oil around the:
• Wringer Frame
• Indexing Plate
• Wringer Post
Replace worn O-rings and bearings as needed.
Inspect
• Cam Shaft O-Ring
• Wringer Stem Bearing
• Lower Roll Shaft O-Ring
Typical signs include oil around the:
• Wringer Frame
• Indexing Plate
• Wringer Post
Replace worn O-rings and bearings as needed.
Why is oil running down the wringer post?
Oil running down the wringer post often indicates water contamination inside the transmission.
Inspect the:
• Vent Hole
• Center Plate Bushing
• Water Seal (A4298)
• Shaft (A5130)
If corrosion is present, replace the damaged components before rebuilding the transmission.
Important: Never lay the washer on its side. Gear oil will drain from the transmission weep hole and continue leaking until emptied. Since these transmissions have no fill plug, refilling to the correct level is difficult.
Inspect the:
• Vent Hole
• Center Plate Bushing
• Water Seal (A4298)
• Shaft (A5130)
If corrosion is present, replace the damaged components before rebuilding the transmission.
Important: Never lay the washer on its side. Gear oil will drain from the transmission weep hole and continue leaking until emptied. Since these transmissions have no fill plug, refilling to the correct level is difficult.
Why is water leaking from my washer?
Most water leaks originate from:
• Tub Gasket
• Center Plate Gasket
• Pump Seals
• Hose Connections
Years of moisture trapped beneath the agitator can also corrode the porcelain tub, causing pinholes.
The BWS04 Stainless Pinhole Tub Repair Ring from Cottage Craft Works permanently repairs these common pinhole leaks. Two versions are available for installation either beneath the center plate or inside the tub. Fits Maytag E, J, and N Series machines, as well as many earlier round-tub models.
• Tub Gasket
• Center Plate Gasket
• Pump Seals
• Hose Connections
Years of moisture trapped beneath the agitator can also corrode the porcelain tub, causing pinholes.
The BWS04 Stainless Pinhole Tub Repair Ring from Cottage Craft Works permanently repairs these common pinhole leaks. Two versions are available for installation either beneath the center plate or inside the tub. Fits Maytag E, J, and N Series machines, as well as many earlier round-tub models.
Why won't my wringer head rotate, or why does it spin freely?
A wringer head that will not rotate is usually caused by the wringer stem rusting to the wringer post.
Apply penetrating oil and work the wringer gently until it frees up.
If the wringer head spins continuously without locking, the Index Slide (A4332) is the most likely cause.
Apply penetrating oil and work the wringer gently until it frees up.
If the wringer head spins continuously without locking, the Index Slide (A4332) is the most likely cause.
Why won't the wringer safety foot pedal work?
See the resource page:
Maytag A5669 Air-Powered Foot Wringer Safety Actuator
The actuator diaphragm may have failed, the rubber air bulb may be cracked, or the actuator may no longer hold air pressure.
Inspect
• Rubber Air Bulb
• Air Line
• Safety Actuator
Test the actuator using only low-pressure air. If it will not hold pressure, replacement diaphragms are not currently available.
Maytag A5669 Air-Powered Foot Wringer Safety Actuator
The actuator diaphragm may have failed, the rubber air bulb may be cracked, or the actuator may no longer hold air pressure.
Inspect
• Rubber Air Bulb
• Air Line
• Safety Actuator
Test the actuator using only low-pressure air. If it will not hold pressure, replacement diaphragms are not currently available.
Why does my washer continue agitating?
Inspect the agitator shaft collar and shifter linkage.
Check for
• Loose Shaft Collar
• Broken Shaft Collar
• Worn or disconnected Shifter Linkage
Reconnect or replace worn components as necessary.
Check for
• Loose Shaft Collar
• Broken Shaft Collar
• Worn or disconnected Shifter Linkage
Reconnect or replace worn components as necessary.
Why won't the wringer lock into position?
Inspect the:
• Index Slide
• Index Plate
• Flat Spring
Replace any worn or damaged parts.
• Index Slide
• Index Plate
• Flat Spring
Replace any worn or damaged parts.
Why does the agitator lift during operation?
A worn spline allows the agitator to rise while washing.
Inspect the:
• Stop Ring
• Rubber Spline
• Plastic Spline
Replace worn splines as needed.
Inspect the:
• Stop Ring
• Rubber Spline
• Plastic Spline
Replace worn splines as needed.
My agitator won't come off. How do I remove it?
Years of detergent buildup can seize the agitator to the shaft.
One method is to place an inflated bicycle inner tube beneath the agitator and use a hand pump—not compressed air—to apply pressure.
Wear safety glasses and stand clear in case the agitator releases suddenly.
If that fails, mechanical removal is required.
Recommended Tool
• Agitator Puller (38323)
A homemade puller using a 2×4, threaded bolt, nuts, and straps may also work.
Never pry against the porcelain tub.
After removal:
• Clean the shaft
• Inspect for tub pinholes
• Replace the seal if necessary
One method is to place an inflated bicycle inner tube beneath the agitator and use a hand pump—not compressed air—to apply pressure.
Wear safety glasses and stand clear in case the agitator releases suddenly.
If that fails, mechanical removal is required.
Recommended Tool
• Agitator Puller (38323)
A homemade puller using a 2×4, threaded bolt, nuts, and straps may also work.
Never pry against the porcelain tub.
After removal:
• Clean the shaft
• Inspect for tub pinholes
• Replace the seal if necessary
How do I remove Gulmite bolts?
Most original Gulmite bolts use a standard 1/2-inch head and can be removed using the Gulmite Socket (38518-A).
Some later machines used a smaller #12 metric-style head that resembles the original but will slip with the Gulmite wrench.
If necessary:
• Cut a slot in the bolt head using a rotary tool.
• Remove it with a large flat-blade screwdriver.
• Replace with the BWS20 Stainless Hardware Kit from Cottage Craft Works.
Some later machines used a smaller #12 metric-style head that resembles the original but will slip with the Gulmite wrench.
If necessary:
• Cut a slot in the bolt head using a rotary tool.
• Remove it with a large flat-blade screwdriver.
• Replace with the BWS20 Stainless Hardware Kit from Cottage Craft Works.
How do I check gear oil level in the transmission or drain it?
Maytag transmissions were designed as sealed units and have neither a dipstick nor a drain plug.
Unless water has entered the transmission or the washer has been laid on its side, it is generally best to leave the original gear oil undisturbed.
Although contrary to common machinery maintenance, many assume 70+-year-old gear oil must be replaced; these slow-speed transmissions generate very little heat, and the lubricant often remains in excellent condition.
Some owners drain oil through the thrust bearing plug and refill through the wringer head weep hole using a small tube. Because there is no practical way to verify the remaining oil level, overfilling is possible.
Lubricant: ISO 460 Gear Oil
Capacity: 16 oz.
Unless water has entered the transmission or the washer has been laid on its side, it is generally best to leave the original gear oil undisturbed.
Although contrary to common machinery maintenance, many assume 70+-year-old gear oil must be replaced; these slow-speed transmissions generate very little heat, and the lubricant often remains in excellent condition.
Some owners drain oil through the thrust bearing plug and refill through the wringer head weep hole using a small tube. Because there is no practical way to verify the remaining oil level, overfilling is possible.
Lubricant: ISO 460 Gear Oil
Capacity: 16 oz.
What lubricants should I use?
Refer to the lubrication chart for the correct lubricants and service intervals. At the very bottom of this chart, alternative lubrication options are provided; many are available locally.
What paint matches the original finish?
For touch-up or restoration, the Amish rebuilding shop recommends:
Rust-Oleum Specialty Appliance Epoxy Spray Paint
Gloss White #7881830
Rust-Oleum Specialty Appliance Epoxy Spray Paint
Gloss White #7881830
How do I remove the legs?
The tub must be removed to access the leg mounting bolts.
Replacement poly legs are available from Cottage Craft Works.
Replacement poly legs are available from Cottage Craft Works.
Are any original accessories still available?
Yes. Cottage Craft Works offers the Maytag Wringer Retro Butter Churn.
Can I replace the drain hose?
Yes. Cottage Craft Works offers all three Maytag drain hose styles.
Can I purchase a rebuilt or new center plate or transmission?
Yes. Cottage Craft Works offers new center plates as well as rebuilt and new Maytag transmissions.
Can I have my wringer head rebuilt?
Yes. Amish-refurbished wringer heads, replacement parts, and new wringer rolls are available through Cottage Craft Works.
Can I purchase a replacement motor?
Yes. Cottage Craft Works offers both quality used original motors and new replacement motors.
Are replacement parts still available?
Yes. Many seals, bearings, wringer components, center plate parts, agitator components, and repair kits remain available.
Visit the complete Maytag Wringer Washer Parts catalog at:
https://cottagecraftworks.com/home-goods/self-sufficient-living/maytag-wringer-washer-parts
Visit the complete Maytag Wringer Washer Parts catalog at:
https://cottagecraftworks.com/home-goods/self-sufficient-living/maytag-wringer-washer-parts
Why does my agitator slow down with heavy loads?
Check for a slipping belt and a worn agitator spline. With the machine off, grab the top of the agitator and try turning it back and forth. If you can move it, the spline probably needs to be replaced with an A4731-R Agitator Spline Rubber. Check if the belt has stretched or is worn to the point where it is loose on the pulley. Replace the belt with an A29 1/2" wide x 31" belt.