Double Peanut Butter Poly Feeder

Feeders are custom-built per order. Please allow 1-2 weeks.

Using the drop-down boxes, choose one color for the roof, then a color for the sides. The roof color selected will then be used for the base. If you would like all the same color, select the same colors for the roof and sides. 

Attract More Wild Birds with the Ultimate Peanut Butter Feeder

If you’re ready to upgrade your backyard bird feeder station, our Double Peanut Butter Poly Feeder delivers superior results. Unlike traditional wood or metal feeders that fade, crack, or rot, this model is crafted from premium ¾″ recycled poly lumber—giving you the durability of poly wood, the eco benefit of recycled material, and the craftsmanship of Amish hand-built quality. 

Key Benefits & Why It Matters

• Built to last: The poly lumber doesn’t dry out, split, or become brittle in extreme cold, and retains over 95 % of its original color even after prolonged exposure. 
  

• Low maintenance: No painting, sealing, or frequent repairs—wash with soap and water if needed.

• Dual peanut compartments: Designed for peanut butter feeding stations to attract woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees, titmice, and other peanut-loving species. All About Birds+1

• Compact but practical size: At 5″ wide × 10½″ high, it’s ideal for hanging under eaves or on a shepherd’s hook without dominating your yard. 
  

• Customizable design: Choose your roof and side colors from a broad palette (Orange, Lime, Turf Green, Lemon Yellow, Milwaukee Brown, Cedar, Weather Wood, Black, Lt Gray, Gray, White, Aruba Blue, Purple, Blue, Red, Cherry Wood)—make it match your outdoor decor or highlight it as an accent piece. 
  

• Eco-friendly choice: Made from recycled plastic bottles, this feeder helps reduce waste while offering a premium backyard wildlife experience. 
  

Which Birds Use It?

Peanut-butter feeders are beautiful to cavity-searching and bark-foraging birds. Expect visitors such as:

• Woodpeckers (Downy, Hairy, Red-bellied)

• Nuthatches & Titmice

• Chickadees and small songbirds
  The feeder is an excellent add-on or complement to your seed, suet, or nut stations—and helps diversify your backyard activity. All About Birds

Specifications & Details

• Dimensions: 5″ W × 10½″ H

• Material: ¾″ recycled poly lumber, stainless-steel screws

• Shipping: Ready-to-ship in approx. one week (allow up to 2 weeks during high-volume gift periods) Cottage Craft Works

• Mounting: Hanging style (choose hook/chain).

• Maintenance: Clean with mild soap and water; avoid harsh detergents.

Why Choose This Feeder Over Others?

Many peanut butter feeders are made of wood that rots, splits, or needs repainting. Others are metal and may scratch, rust, or fade. With our product, you get:

• A rot-free, weather-proof structure built to remain attractive season after season.

• Deep-embedded colors—“color impregnated in the recycling process”—so scratches don’t reveal a different underlying hue. Cottage Craft Works

• Full customization of roof and side color to match any backyard theme.

• The feather-friendly shape that gives birds safe access to peanut butter without interfering with your seed feeders.

Care & Tips for Best Results

1. Hang the feeder at least 5-6 ft from the ground, near trees or natural cover, to encourage visiting birds and discourage squirrels.

2. Use natural, unsalted peanut butter (the smoother the better) and fill the pockets or jar portion as directed.

3. Clean the feeder every 2–3 weeks or after heavy rain to prevent mold. The poly lumber surface makes it easy.

4. During hot months, consider moving the feeder into partial shade so peanut butter doesn't melt excessively.

5. Pair this feeder with other food types (seed, suet) to attract a wider variety of birds and keep them coming back.

Ready to upgrade your backyard bird-feeding experience? Select your color combination now and add this durable, Amish-crafted peanut butter feeder to your yard. Your wild birds will thank you—and you’ll enjoy the show.